Julio Orozco
Search
Bright open-plan dining room with an oak table, taupe chairs and pale wood flooring overlooking a private autumn garden in the South Bay.

Gilroy and Morgan Hill Home Prices, Square Foot by Square Foot

November 19, 2026

In October 2026, the median single-family home in Morgan Hill sold for $1,837,500, its highest monthly median of the year, and the median in Gilroy sold for $1,150,000. That is a gap of about 60 percent between neighboring South County towns. In the same month, the median price per square foot was $632 in Morgan Hill and $575 in Gilroy, according to the Santa Clara County Association of REALTORS® October 2026 report. Per square foot, the gap is about 10 percent.

In January 2026 that per-square-foot gap was about 52 percent. Across ten months, Morgan Hill's price per square foot fell while Gilroy's rose, and the two towns now price living space within roughly a tenth of each other. Most of what still separates their medians is the size of the homes that sell. For a buyer choosing between the two, Morgan Hill has more room to negotiate this fall, even though its headline number is at a high.

Ten months of the two towns side by side

The table below follows each town's single-family median price per square foot and active inventory through 2026, all from the association's monthly city reports.

Month 2026 Gilroy $/sq ft Morgan Hill $/sq ft Gilroy inventory Morgan Hill inventory
January $469 $714 52 34
February $521 $681 71 45
March $489 $670 92 60
April $539 $695 90 79
May $552 $665 95 79
June $537 $683 95 75
July $504 $674 97 85
August $536 $634 90 72
September $531 $618 87 82
October $575 $632 89 90

From March through October, Gilroy's inventory stayed between 87 and 97 homes every month, and its median sale price moved only between $1.10 million and $1.20 million. Gilroy's median per square foot climbed from the high $400s early in the year to $575 in October. Morgan Hill's inventory went from 34 in January to 90 in October. Its median per square foot reached $714 in January, slid to $618 in September and finished October at $632.

Where Morgan Hill's record median comes from

A median price rises for two reasons. Comparable homes start selling for more, or more of the homes that sell are the bigger, pricier ones. Morgan Hill's October looks like the second case. The median sale price rose about 20 percent from January to October, from $1,525,000 to $1,837,500, while the median price per square foot fell about 11 percent, from $714 to $632, over the same ten months. A falling price per foot alongside a rising median fits a mix of sales tilted toward larger homes.

Dividing each October median by its median price per square foot gives a rough sense of scale. It works out to about 2,900 square feet in Morgan Hill and 2,000 in Gilroy. It is a rough calculation, since two medians do not describe one specific house. It still shows where the 60 percent gap comes from. Much of what looks like a Morgan Hill premium is a Morgan Hill house being bigger.

October was also Morgan Hill's thinnest month of the year for closings, with 20 sales. With that few sales, a handful of large homes can set the median.

How much room each town gives a buyer this fall

Dividing active inventory by a month's closings gives a rough count of how many months the current supply would last at that pace. In October 2026, Gilroy's 89 homes against 29 closings came to about three months. Morgan Hill's 90 homes against 20 closings came to about four and a half. Sunnyvale's 51 homes against 41 closings came to about one and a quarter months.

The prices buyers paid relative to list price follow the same order. In October 2026, Gilroy sellers received 98 percent of list price and Morgan Hill sellers 99 percent. Sunnyvale sellers got 110 percent, Los Altos sellers 112 percent, and the county as a whole 104 percent. In South County, a buyer is negotiating from the list price, not bidding up from it.

The year-over-year change separates the two towns more clearly than any single month does. In October 2025, Morgan Hill had 57 homes in inventory and 37 closings, which is about a month and a half of supply. A year later it had 90 homes and 20 closings. That works out to 58 percent more inventory and close to half as many sales. Gilroy went from 90 homes and 36 closings in October 2025 to 89 and 29 in October 2026, and its sale-to-list ratio was 98 percent both years. Gilroy's supply barely changed, while Morgan Hill's tripled when measured in months.

A Morgan Hill buyer this fall is shopping in a town with more homes listed than a year ago and fewer competing buyers closing on them. A Gilroy buyer is shopping in about the same market as last year, at a slightly higher price per square foot.

What Gilroy is adding, and how much

Gilroy's permit records show how little new housing of any kind has been added. In calendar year 2025, according to the City of Gilroy's 2025 Housing Element Annual Progress Report, the city issued building permits for 37 new homes, and 10 of them were in the above-moderate, market-rate category. Those 37 permits are a small number next to the roughly 90 single-family homes listed in Gilroy in a typical month of 2026.

The residential projects approved this year are also small. The city's approved-project log dated July 10, 2026 lists Glen Loma Town Center Flex, 42 units with KB Home, approved July 7, 2026. It sits south of West Luchessa Avenue and north of Loma Ranch Street, between West Tenth Street and Miller Avenue. The same log lists 42 market-rate townhomes at 95 Howson Street, approved May 4, 2026. KB Home also lists a Gilroy community called Palomino Heights as coming soon, without pricing.

The largest residential project underway in Gilroy is rental housing. Park 315, at 315 Las Animas Avenue, was approved in a City of Gilroy letter dated February 6, 2026 for 530 multifamily rental units, 106 of them affordable units. The city's project log records building permits for Park 315 issued June 22, 2026. It adds homes to Gilroy's rental market. For a buyer, it does not add to the roughly 90 single-family homes on the market in a typical month.

The attached-home market tells the same story. In October 2026, Gilroy had one condo or townhome sale, at $460,000, and eight on the market. Morgan Hill had six sales at a median of $889,995, with 34 on the market. A buyer who wants a townhome in South County has far more to choose from in Morgan Hill, while Gilroy is almost entirely a single-family market.

Reading a single month in a town this size

Gilroy closes roughly 20 to 50 single-family homes a month. At that volume, a few high-end sales can pull an average far from the median. In October 2025, Gilroy's average sale price was $1,445,077 against a median of $1,132,500. In October 2026 the average was $1,152,568 and the median $1,150,000. Both months came from the same town and the same kind of market. What differed was which homes happened to close.

Several patterns held across months. Gilroy's inventory stayed near 90 from March through October. Morgan Hill's price per square foot was lower in August, September and October than in any of the first seven months of 2026. And Morgan Hill's supply has gone up while its closings have gone down for a year. Any single month in either town is too small a sample to carry much weight on its own.

Quick answers

Is Gilroy still the less expensive town?

Yes. Gilroy's median sale price was about $690,000 below Morgan Hill's in October 2026. Per square foot, though, the difference was $57, down from $245 in January 2026. A buyer comparing homes of similar size in the two towns will find the prices closer than the medians suggest.

Which town has more room to negotiate right now?

Based on the October 2026 figures, Morgan Hill. It had about four and a half months of supply against Gilroy's three, and its inventory was up 58 percent from October 2025. Gilroy's conditions are close to where they were a year ago.

Will new construction change Gilroy's market soon?

The two residential projects on the city's July 2026 approved list add up to 84 units across Glen Loma Town Center Flex and 95 Howson Street. That is small next to a market that keeps about 90 single-family homes listed in a typical month. The 530-unit Park 315 project is rental housing.

If you're weighing Gilroy against Morgan Hill, the useful comparison is a home of a given size on a given street, not the two towns' medians. If you'd like to talk through the homes you're considering in either town, I'm glad to help. Visit Julio Orozco or start with the Gilroy and Morgan Hill pages. Let's Connect.

Your Trusted Real Estate Partner

More than a REALTOR®, Julio is a trusted advisor dedicated to helping clients navigate every step of the real estate journey with confidence.